PCAMTSII Scoring Criteria

Version: PCAMTSIIv1.0.0-alpha

The rating criteria and their corresponding interpretations are derived from ChatGPT and New Bing, and special thanks are given to their contributions to the establishment of this standard.

Introduction

Note

PCAMTSII stands for Plot, Character, Animation, Music, Theme, Style, Innovation and Impact.

It is a comprehensive criterion for evaluating works based on plot, characters, animation, music, style, innovation, and impact. The word is pronounced [piːkæmtsɪː], similar to the English combination of "peak" and "see."

Note

PCAMTSII has several advantages:

• It covers many aspects of evaluating the work and can comprehensively analyze and evaluate the work.
• It can help the audience improve their aesthetic ability and appreciation level and discover the strengths and weaknesses of the work.
• It can facilitate communication and discussion between the audience, allowing them to share their opinions and feelings.

PCAMTSII also has some disadvantages:

• It may be too complex and cumbersome for quick and simple evaluations.
• It may overlook other evaluative factors, such as personal preferences, emotions, background, etc.
• It may cause the audience to be too rational and objective and lose the fun and emotion of experiencing the work.

Info

Some of the copywriting was inspired by WLOP

P Plot

Plot refers to the story content of the work, including plot, structure, logic, rhythm, etc.

• Knight: The plot lacks logic, coherence and appeal, full of plot holes, contradictions and boring elements that make people feel bored and confused.
• Black Knight: The plot has a certain logic, coherence and appeal, but there are still some plot holes, contradictions and boring elements that make people feel unsatisfied and disappointed.
• Templar: The plot has good logic, coherence, and appeal, which can make people feel interested and expectant, but there is still room for improvement.
• Angel: The plot is highly logical, coherent and attractive, able to surprise and satisfy, with wonderful ups and downs and climaxes.
• Asura: The plot is extremely logical, coherent and attractive, able to shock and admire, with deep themes and allegories, creating classic scenes and lines.

C Character

Character refers to the character image in the work, including character, motivation, growth, etc.

• Knight: The characters lack personality, character, and charm and are full of stereotypes, clichés, and uninteresting settings that make people feel disgusted and disinterested.
• Black Knight: The characters have a certain personality, traits and charm, but there are still some stereotypes, clichés and uninteresting settings that feel less deep and realistic.
• Templar: Characters have good personalities, traits and charm that can be liked and sympathetic, but there is still some room for development.
• Angel: The character has a high personality, traits and charm, can be admired and admired, has a rich heart and growth, and forms a unique style and temperament.
• Asura: The character has a very high personality, traits and charm, is able to be admired and admired, has deep thoughts and values, and creates classic images and impressions.

A Animation

Animation refers to the visual effects of the work, including style, details, colors, painting quality, action performance, etc.

• Knight: Animation lacks beauty, detail, and dynamics and is full of rough, blurry, and stiff images that make people feel uncomfortable and disgusted.
• Black Knight: Animation has a certain aesthetic, detail, and dynamic, but there are still some rough, blurry, and stiff graphics that feel less clear and fluid.
• Templar: Animation has good aesthetics, detail, and dynamism that makes people feel comfortable and appreciated, but there is still room for improvement.
• Angel: Animation has a high aesthetic, detail, and dynamics, can make people feel astonished and amazed, with exquisite lines and colors, showing excellent techniques and level.
• Asura: Animation is extremely beautiful, detailed, and dynamic, capable of shocking and awe-inspiring, with gorgeous light and atmosphere, creating visual wonders and works of art.

M Music

Music refers to the sound effects of the work, including soundtracks, voice actors, OP, ED, etc.

• Knight: Music lacks melody, rhythm and emotion, and is full of monotonous, harsh, and incongruous music that makes people feel irritated and resistant.
• Black Knight: The music has a certain melody, rhythm, and emotion, but there are still some monotonous, harsh, and incongruous music that makes people feel less beautiful and cooperative.
• Templar: Music has good melodies, rhythms, and emotions that make people feel pleasant and engaged, but there is still room for improvement.
• Angel: Music has a high melody, rhythm, and emotion, can make people feel excited and resonant, has a beautiful melody and a strong atmosphere,
  Demonstrated excellent creation and performance.
• Asura: Music with extremely high melodies, rhythms and emotions, capable of shocking and admiring, with deep thoughts and values, creating classic ideas and influences.

T Theme

The theme refers to the thoughts, values, emotions, etc. that the work wants to convey.

• Knight: The theme lacks depth, breadth, and meaning and is full of empty, superficial, and boring themes that make people feel uninspired and uninterested.
• Black Knight: The theme has a certain depth, breadth, and meaning, but there are still some hollow, superficial, and boring themes that don't feel deep enough and interesting.
• Templar: The theme has good depth, breadth and meaning, which can be thought-provoking and inspiring, but there is still room for expansion.
• Angel: The theme has a high depth, breadth, and meaning, can make people feel moved and perceptible, has rich connotation and extension, and shows the author's insights and attitude.
• Asura: The theme has great depth, breadth, and meaning, can be shocking and amazing, has a deep philosophy and values, and creates classic ideas and influences.

S Style

Style refers to the type, atmosphere, characteristics, etc. of the work.

• Knight: The style lacks character, unity, and beauty, full of boring, cluttered, and incongruous styles that make people feel uncomfortable and disgusted.
• Black Knight: The style has a certain character, unity, and beauty, but there are still some tedious, cluttered, and incongruous styles that feel less clear and fluid.
• Templar: The style has good character, unity, and beauty, which can make people feel comfortable and appreciated, but there is still room for improvement.
• Angel: The style has a high character, unity, and beauty, can make people feel astonished and amazed, with unique colors and atmospheres,
  Showing the personality and taste of the author.
• Asura: The style is extremely characteristic, unified, and beautiful, capable of making people feel shocked and awe-inspiring, with gorgeous light and atmosphere, creating visual wonders and works of art.

I Innovation

Innovation refers to whether the work has novel settings, stories, expression techniques, etc.

• Knight: Innovation lacks novelty, breakthrough, and impact, full of old, imitative, and useless innovations, making people feel bored and disinterested.
• Black Knight: Innovation has certain novelty, breakthroughs, and impacts, but there are still some old, imitative, and useless innovations that feel less new and useful.
• Templar: Innovation has good novelty, breakthroughs, and impacts, and can surprise and stimulate curiosity, but there is still room for improvement.
• Angel: Innovation has high novelty, breakthroughs, and impacts, can amaze and admire, has a unique concept and realization, and shows the talent and courage of the author.
• Asura: Innovation is extremely innovative, breakthrough, and impactful, capable of being shocking and awe-inspiring, with unprecedented creativity and contribution, and has created historical milestones and classics.

I Impact

Impact refers to the influence and contribution of a work to the audience, society, culture, etc.

• Knight: The impact lacks persistence, breadth, and depth, full of ephemeral, limited, and subtle influences that feel irrelevant and forgettable.
• Black Knight: The impact has some persistence, breadth, and far-reaching effects, but there are still some short-lived, limited, and weak effects that feel less important and memorable.
• Templar: Influences are durable, widespread, and far-reaching, and can be valued and remembered, but there is still room for expansion.
• Angel: The impact is highly persistent, widespread, and far-reaching, can be respected and celebrated, has a long-lasting span and scope,
  Showing the value and status of the work.
• Asura: Influences are extremely persistent, widespread, and far-reaching, capable of being awe-inspiring and worshipped, with timeless history and significance, showing the greatness and influence of the work.